201 – Live at Revolution Hall in Portland (2017)

The '201 - Live at Revolution Hall in Portland (2017)' episode of 'My Favorite Murder' features co-hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark engaging with a lively Portland audience. The episode opens with the hosts bantering about their experiences in Portland, including a peculiar estate sale and their mutual love for crime scene photos. The conversation transitions into a discussion about various books and personal anecdotes, including the pair's matching outfits and their caffeine-fueled energy, which sets a humorous and intimate tone for the live show.

As the episode progresses, Karen and Georgia delve into their respective murder stories, both of which are rooted in Oregon. Georgia recounts the chilling tale of William Scott Smith, a serial killer from Salem, Oregon, who was convicted of multiple murders in the 1980s. She describes his heinous crimes, the discovery of his victims' bodies, and the eventual capture and sentencing of Smith. Georgia's narrative is detailed and engaging, providing a comprehensive account of Smith's criminal activities and the impact on the local community.

Karen's segment focuses on the mysterious and deadly allure of Crater Lake. She combines historical facts with eerie anecdotes, including a series of deaths and disappearances linked to the lake. Karen's storytelling is rich with descriptions of the lake's beauty and the legends surrounding it, creating a captivating and haunting atmosphere. She concludes with a hometown murder story shared by an audience member, Alissa, about the discovery of a fugitive's body by her cousin, adding a personal and local touch to the Portland show.

Throughout the episode, Karen and Georgia's chemistry and comedic timing shine, as they effortlessly blend humor with the macabre details of the murders. The episode is punctuated by audience interactions, adding to the unique energy of the live recording. The hosts' ability to connect with the crowd and each other, while discussing such dark subject matter, is a testament to the podcast's appeal and the community it has fostered.